
Photo credit: JCHS
Delivered at Hakhel, Monday, November 16, 2026. Each Monday, JCHS students and faculty gather for Hakhel, our all-school assembly, named for the biblical mitzvah of gathering the whole community together. I close it with a short dvar Torah, a reflection on the week’s Torah portion. This week’s came right after our theater company performed an excerpt from the fall musical, Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, which turned out to matter.
A Table Full of WordsNext week many of us will be sitting around a Thanksgiving table. I asked the students how many would be at a table of more than five people. More than ten? Twenty? Then I asked how many of them knew there would be at least one conversation at that table that could go… sideways. That got a laugh, and many knowing looks.Tables are where words happen. Words can bring people closer, but words can push some away.
The Tongue and the Lioness’s Milk
So I told them an old rabbinic story about words, found in Midrash Tehillim (Midrash Tehillim 39). A king of Persia is dying. His doctors say there is only one cure: the milk of a lioness. A brave man volunteers. He goes to the lion’s den with a herd of goats. On the first day he stands far off and tosses the lioness a goat. The next day he comes a little closer. Day after day he draws nearer, until she lets him close enough to milk her.
On the road home he falls asleep, and in his dream the parts of his body start to argue about which of them deserves the credit. The feet say, “Without us, he never gets there.” The hands say, “We did the milking.” Then the tongue speaks up: “Without me, you’re all worthless.” Everyone laughs. “You? You live in the dark behind a fence of teeth. You don’t even have a bone.” The tongue answers, “Today you’ll see.”
The man reaches the palace, bows before the king, and says, “Your Majesty, I’ve brought you the milk of a dog.” The king orders him hanged. As he is led away, his whole body is shaking, and the tongue asks the others, “Now do you admit who’s greatest?” “Yes! Save us!”
Back before the king, the tongue speaks again: “Forgive me, Majesty, I misspoke. It’s lioness’s milk. Drink and be healed.” The king drinks, and he is healed.
The story ends with a verse from Proverbs, “Death and life are in the power of the tongue.” (Proverbs 18:21)
Same man. Same milk. Same king. But one word changed everything.
Yaakov’s Answer
This week’s Torah portion, Vayetzei, has a moment where we see that power at work, and it comes from someone I would least expect. Yaakov (Jacob) has married two sisters, Leah and Rachel. Leah has child after child. Rachel, the wife Yaakov loves, has none. Her pain spills out in an anguished cry: “Give me children, or I am as good as dead” (Genesis 30:1).
Rachel is in deep pain. And how does Yaakov answer her? He gets angry. Defensive. “Am I in God’s place!?!” (Genesis 30:2). Technically, he’s right. He isn’t God, and he can’t fix this. But the Rabbis were not interested in whether he was technically right. In Bereshit Rabbah, a 5th century collection of rabbinic teachings on Genesis, they imagine God rebuking Yaakov: “Is that the way one answers someone in distress? As you live, your sons are destined to stand before her son” (Bereshit Rabbah 71:7).
And they do. Our students had just watched them on stage: Joseph and his brothers. Years later, those brothers will stand, frightened, before Joseph, Rachel’s son, in Egypt, begging for bread.
What strikes me is what Yaakov didn’t do. He didn’t lie. He didn’t curse. He didn’t spread a rumor. What he said wasn't bad in those ways. Still, he was frustrated, and he let his frustration do the talking. I think much of the harm we cause with words looks just like that:
A sharp answer when someone was hurting.
A joke at the wrong moment.
The text we sent because we were annoyed.
Who Listened
A few verses later the Torah tells us that God “remembered Rachel… and listened to her” (Genesis 30:22). God did what Yaakov didn’t. God listened.
And years later, Yaakov’s son Joseph gets it right. When he finally reveals himself to his brothers, they are terrified. They expect him to settle a score. Afterall they had sold him into slavery. Instead he says, “I am Joseph… Now don’t be distressed, and don’t be angry with yourselves” (Genesis 45:3–5). He speaks to their fear, not to their guilt.
Yaakov answered the problem. Yosef, his son, answered the person.
At Our Tables
So I asked our students to try something at their Thanksgiving tables. First: when someone near you is upset, before you answer, ask yourself one question. Am I answering the problem, or the person? Second: once, on purpose, use your words to heal. A true compliment. A thank-you. An apology you owe. It takes only a few seconds. I offer the same two things to everyone reading this, as we head toward our own tables.
Answer the person. Be the tongue that heals.
Each week our whole school gathers for Hakhel — all of our students and all of our faculty and staff, together in one room. We took the name from the mitzvah in Deuteronomy 31, where the people are called together to hear Torah. It is a time for announcements, celebration of community, honoring student accomplishments. I close the gathering with a short dvar Torah. This is what I offered on the Monday of Parashat Vayera.





